There is a fun little debate over heavy missiles spawned CCP Fozzie talking about reducing range and damage of HMs. Read the comments of that blog post for fun.
At the crux of the argument seems to be the underlying strengths of various battlecruisers, the weapons they fit, and range. In the interest of full disclosure, I fly Drakes and Tengus a lot, and usually they sport HMLs, either T2 or Faction flavors. And I think the hatred of those two ships using missiles comes not so much from the damage projection as from the rather outlandish interplay of slot layout, cap usage, and the location of armor and shield tanking modules.
I'm a relentless fit experimenter. I love trying to come up with crazy tanks while still putting out enough DPS to complete L4 missions in something resembling a sane amount of time. A common thematic problem I run into is the fact that a shield tanked ship, on average, can almost always get a better tank and a better gank because of the slot layout when designing to PvE activities as compared to an armor tank. Some ships buck this trend when you factor in drone bonuses, but overall, a Drake will do more damage, around 300 dps, and have a bigger tank, by a lot, and not run into cap issues when compared to other BC hulls. This is most apparent in the BC classes, where marginal trade-offs are not always so marginal.
The imbalance is such that I have focused my training almost entirely on sub-BS hulls, and poured SP in two accounts into the Drake > Tengu pathway simply because it makes the most sense from a time/isk/risk perspective. The extra time training into BS sized hulls and weapons, for a new-ish player is just silly. I appreciate the idea of tiericide, as I would love to be able to justify flying more ships with the same relative effectiveness. But the HML debate brings to mind considerations of how the various weapon systems work, apart from any game balance considerations and I have always been left confused.
Space is a vacuum. Once you fire an object, it will keep going at the speed you fired it in a straight line until it hits something or gravity deflects the trajectory. Weapons in Eve do not follow this logic. Lasers mysteriously disappear, which is ludicrous. Projectiles and hybrids have some weird optimal/falloff artifacts that function the same way. But there is no fundamental reason why up to 20km a solid slug would fly, and then at 20.1km it would vanish from the universe. Missile collision detection apparently fails after the fuel runs out. I don't know how real missiles are designed, but that also seems silly. It's all pear-shaped in the name of game balance.
So maybe, when looking at weapons attributes, the focus should stop being range, and should instead change entirely to fitting, targeting, tracking, damage type and cap usage. I recognize that the limitations of technology and game balance require grid size limitations and some sort of range limitations. Perhaps class weapon range to the grid, and make up for the other factors? For example, frigates only have enough computer space to accurately track vessels to a certain range, but if a target is stationary, as long as you point in the right direction, boom. This is a wholesale redesign of the game, but it could take some weight off of weird justifications of range, and focus it back into ship modules and piloting strategies.
Yes it's crazy, and this will never happen, but the physics of Eve weapons have always nagged at certain portions of my brain.
Showing posts with label Fitting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fitting. Show all posts
Friday, September 21, 2012
Thursday, May 17, 2012
Fail Fits and Rookies
Edit: A commenter noted that I am wrong about the tutorials teaching players to use multiple tank types. This is very probably right. I do no think that alters my fundamental point.
Read this over at Poetic, and the comments. Always a fun time, reading the comments. I'm torn on how to handle fail fits. I'm sure I have some fail fits that I like, elite players be damned. I also want to laugh at fail fits. But then I wonder, did that fail fit player buy some PLEX and go nuts, only to get his investment all blowed up and not understand why? And why do so many people ignore advice from those that blew them up? Questions without answers. But one thing could be done.
CCP could make the tutorials actually teach people about fits instead of having tutorial missions that encourage fail fits in a roundabout way. I'm talking about those starter tutorial chains that give you a frigate, then give you an armor repper, then give you a shield booster. And each mission tells you to use that specific module. Not very good. Arydanika talked about this on her blog a few weeks or months ago with some low-sec style guys, and they came to the conclusion that there should be fitting tutorials. I agree.
So I propose, in the same vein, the following tutorials to be added as a Capsuleer Ship Fitting chain, given to you at the same time as the other newbie tutorials, or possible after the military/combat chain:
Read this over at Poetic, and the comments. Always a fun time, reading the comments. I'm torn on how to handle fail fits. I'm sure I have some fail fits that I like, elite players be damned. I also want to laugh at fail fits. But then I wonder, did that fail fit player buy some PLEX and go nuts, only to get his investment all blowed up and not understand why? And why do so many people ignore advice from those that blew them up? Questions without answers. But one thing could be done.
CCP could make the tutorials actually teach people about fits instead of having tutorial missions that encourage fail fits in a roundabout way. I'm talking about those starter tutorial chains that give you a frigate, then give you an armor repper, then give you a shield booster. And each mission tells you to use that specific module. Not very good. Arydanika talked about this on her blog a few weeks or months ago with some low-sec style guys, and they came to the conclusion that there should be fitting tutorials. I agree.
So I propose, in the same vein, the following tutorials to be added as a Capsuleer Ship Fitting chain, given to you at the same time as the other newbie tutorials, or possible after the military/combat chain:
- Charge the Batteries: Teaching capacitor basics.
- Plugging in the Chips: Fitting to CPU requirements.
- Turning on the Lights: Fitting to powergrid requirements.
- She Can't Take Anymore, Captain!: Shield tanking.
- Structural Integrity: Armor tanking.
- Fire When You See the Whites of Their Eyes: Close range fitting.
- Get Under Their Guns: Close range combat
- One Shot, One Kill: Long range fitting.
- Tack to Starboard: Long range fighting and kiting.
- We're Going to Need a Bigger Ship: Moving up to a destroyer.
There, I made names and topics. CCP can do the rest.
Wednesday, January 18, 2012
Failing at (Internet Spaceship) Life
I saved up and trained up over the last month or so, and finally got myself into the ship I wanted to fly since I saw one in action, the Tengu. My fit was a rather standard mission running fit, as I recently moved to a new section of Empire and have been grinding standing for various characters and stocking up on the isk while I decide on my next move in Eve. My fit ran along these lines:
[Tengu, Mission]
Tengu Defensive - Amplification Node
Tengu Electronics - Dissolution Sequencer
Tengu Engineering - Augmented Capacitor Reservoir
Tengu Offensive - Accelerated Ejection Bay
Tengu Propulsion - Fuel Catalyst
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Republic Fleet 10MN Afterburner
Caldari Navy Shield Boost Amplifier
Pithum C-Type Medium Shield Booster
Invulnerability Field II
Invulnerability Field II
Photon Scattering Field II
Caldari Navy Ballistic Control System
Caldari Navy Ballistic Control System
Caldari Navy Ballistic Control System
Power Diagnostic System II
Medium Capacitor Control Circuit II
Medium Capacitor Control Circuit II
Medium Capacitor Control Circuit I
As far as Tengus go, this is not a terribly expensive fit, coming in around the 1.2 B mark when I got the whole thing together. I have a few things to say about the 'Gu. First, it is an amazing ship in the role I built it for. Fast, agile, and deft at handling most PvE encounters. The DPS is very nice, about 450 or so, depending on what missiles I load into the launchers. The tank is half speed, and three quarters shield booster. Yes, that adds up to over 100% for those inclined to math. The range is about 110 km, which is further than all but the farthest mission spawns. The 'Gu is also aesthetically pleasing in a odd, inherently Caldari way.
There are some downsides to the 'Gu. It makes most level 4 missions trivial to the point of boredom. It's a bit of a panic to fly the first few days, due to the enormous value of the ship. I found myself much more likely to warp off encounters when seeing the shield tank take a few hits, and I really watch gates and local while flying it. But most of all, the 'Gu is so mind numbingly effective at most things in Empire that it lulls you into a false sense of security after a week or so. You probably saw this coming: I lost my Tengu not too long after I built it, because I was an idiot.
The details of this death are very simple, and in hindsight the cause of death was hubris. I had been pulling missions like candy, and while puttering around wiping out fleets of Sansha, I started to build a nice little Manticore on an alt. Side note - Grimmash is a very capable stealth bomber pilot with most missile skills hanging out in the 4s and 5s, so targeting a frigate with a torpedo, while not the most efficient using of isk, will result in space debris within a few shots. The pilot I made the Manticore for does not have such nice support skills, and I forgot this fact. So I built the Manty, pulled a Worlds Collide, looked at the Eve-Survival report, and made a series of mistakes which I shall elucidate for you, dear reader.
[Tengu, Mission]
Tengu Defensive - Amplification Node
Tengu Electronics - Dissolution Sequencer
Tengu Engineering - Augmented Capacitor Reservoir
Tengu Offensive - Accelerated Ejection Bay
Tengu Propulsion - Fuel Catalyst
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Heavy Missile Launcher II, Scourge Heavy Missile
Republic Fleet 10MN Afterburner
Caldari Navy Shield Boost Amplifier
Pithum C-Type Medium Shield Booster
Invulnerability Field II
Invulnerability Field II
Photon Scattering Field II
Caldari Navy Ballistic Control System
Caldari Navy Ballistic Control System
Caldari Navy Ballistic Control System
Power Diagnostic System II
Medium Capacitor Control Circuit II
Medium Capacitor Control Circuit II
Medium Capacitor Control Circuit I
As far as Tengus go, this is not a terribly expensive fit, coming in around the 1.2 B mark when I got the whole thing together. I have a few things to say about the 'Gu. First, it is an amazing ship in the role I built it for. Fast, agile, and deft at handling most PvE encounters. The DPS is very nice, about 450 or so, depending on what missiles I load into the launchers. The tank is half speed, and three quarters shield booster. Yes, that adds up to over 100% for those inclined to math. The range is about 110 km, which is further than all but the farthest mission spawns. The 'Gu is also aesthetically pleasing in a odd, inherently Caldari way.
There are some downsides to the 'Gu. It makes most level 4 missions trivial to the point of boredom. It's a bit of a panic to fly the first few days, due to the enormous value of the ship. I found myself much more likely to warp off encounters when seeing the shield tank take a few hits, and I really watch gates and local while flying it. But most of all, the 'Gu is so mind numbingly effective at most things in Empire that it lulls you into a false sense of security after a week or so. You probably saw this coming: I lost my Tengu not too long after I built it, because I was an idiot.
The details of this death are very simple, and in hindsight the cause of death was hubris. I had been pulling missions like candy, and while puttering around wiping out fleets of Sansha, I started to build a nice little Manticore on an alt. Side note - Grimmash is a very capable stealth bomber pilot with most missile skills hanging out in the 4s and 5s, so targeting a frigate with a torpedo, while not the most efficient using of isk, will result in space debris within a few shots. The pilot I made the Manticore for does not have such nice support skills, and I forgot this fact. So I built the Manty, pulled a Worlds Collide, looked at the Eve-Survival report, and made a series of mistakes which I shall elucidate for you, dear reader.
- The most vital mistake: Angels use webs AND scram, not just webs. I misread the mission report and saw "5 webs" not "5 webs/scrams".
- The 'Gu, although decent at taking out frigates, will not atomize 5 elite NPC frigates faster than a small fleet of cruisers and battleships will break a medium shield booster, even if it is deadspace gear.
- A SB is not the suitable suport ship to take out said elite NPC frigates.
- A speed tank is absolutely useless when you something like 4-6 active webs hindering propulsion.
- Use of kiting and good transversal is the difference between tanking with ease and slowly watching something burn with you in it.
And not so much a mistake but a fun fact: 45 seconds is about how long it takes to go through the stages of denial, anger, bargaining and acceptance when watching your tank break in the most expensive ship you own. Oddly, I skipped depression unti la few days later when I saw a friend flying her Muninn and wanted to flex my DPS muscles, only to remember that I was now back in my Drake/Raven combo team.
The most interesting part of the whole thing was how much I didn't rage. I always figured losing a ship that expensive would sting more, but overall I think having had, and lost, the 'Gu reinvigorated Eve for me. I've been trying more approaches to mission running instead of just grinding things out, and it lead to me undergoing a rather profitable scanning run in order to avoid missions. It made me remember that unpredictability is more interesting than stasis, and that sometime a big loss is actually a good thing.
Tuesday, November 29, 2011
Guide: Making Money 101 – Mission Running
Missioning
Simply put, mission running means going to an NPC agent and
accepting a mission, completing it, and getting paid. Missioning pays well… once you hit the level
4 agents. To get there you need to grind
your status up from (probably) neutral.
You will probably want to do this with a useful corporation. What does useful mean? I define it as an NPC corp that has fringe
benefits besides just making ik. Good
Loyalty Point rewards, geographically convenient Jump Clone access, and better
refining rates can all be gained by choosing wisely.
My recommendation is to ask in your corp what NPC corps
people have or are grinding standing with and work towards those. Often this will be one of the faction
navies. This gives you the advantage of
working towards all of the benefits mentioned above while having people to
grind with.
So how do you make money off missions? There are actually a number of ways:
- Mission pirate bounties
- Mission rewards
- Salvage
- Loyalty Point Farming
The first two take care of themselves. Once you hit level four missions, you can
actually make about 10-20 million per mission if you kill everything and do it
within the time frame for the bonus.
Salvage is awesome (in my opinion) and I am going to cover it a bit
later. LP farming can be trickier. I made a spreadsheet to calculate isk per LP. You may want to do this, or just save LP to
spend on faction gear you want.
Battlecruisers and You
So what should you fly to run missions? I’ll refer to the holy trinity of MMOs: you can flit to some combination of DPS/Tank/Healer
(logisitics in Eve). Eve also has the
bonus that most mission ships will be self-repping, either through shield regen
or armor repair. Also, there are almost
no missions in levels 1 through 4 where a dedicated logistics pilot is
needed. The rule of thumb for level 4 missions
is that your damage (DPS or gank) and armor repair or shield regeneration
(Tank) need to total 1000 points. I would argue DPS really needs to be over 200
to be in anyway effective, and tank only needs to be above 300-400 in small,
specific situations, but your mileage may vary.
I went Incursus >
Vexor > Myrmidon > Drake. I also
started Gallente and then cross-trained to Caldari. Although it is cliché, a shield tanked Drake can
give you a lot of leeway to learn mission mechanics while not having to worry
much about your ship. Below is a very boring but strong as hell Drake template. A few things to note about this fit: as your
get better at understanding missions, you can probably start sacrificing shield
moduless in exchange for additional BCS units and an afterburner. The point below is to show you a relatively cheap and effective ship, not the be-all end-all of mission fits. The Drone Link Augmentor is meant to give
your light drones more time to intercept pesky frigates. Low missiles skills can cause frigs to be a
real nightmare for the Drake.
[Drake, L4 Tank McBoring]
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Drone Link Augmentor I
Large Shield Extender II
Large Shield Extender II
Large Shield Extender II
Invulnerability Field II
Invulnerability Field II
Shield Recharger II
Shield Power Relay II
Shield Power Relay II
Power Diagnostic System II
Ballistic Control System II
Medium Core Defence Field Purger I
Medium Core Defence Field Purger I
Medium Core Defence Field Purger I
[Drake, L4 Tank McBoring]
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Advanced 'Limos' Heavy Missile Bay I, Scourge Heavy Missile
Drone Link Augmentor I
Large Shield Extender II
Large Shield Extender II
Large Shield Extender II
Invulnerability Field II
Invulnerability Field II
Shield Recharger II
Shield Power Relay II
Shield Power Relay II
Power Diagnostic System II
Ballistic Control System II
Medium Core Defence Field Purger I
Medium Core Defence Field Purger I
Medium Core Defence Field Purger I
Other ships to consider are the Hurricane (Eve’s jack of all
trades battlecruiser), a Gila (For those that want an exotic missile/shield/drone
boat) or the Myrmidon. These are all
battlecruisers, but I have flown all of them in level four missions, and I
recommend you learn how to do so as well.
I think the Myrmidon is also very versatile. You can fly it with any turret system as it
has no weapon bonuses to lose, can be shield or armor tanked, and can fit two
flights each of medium and light drones, or more creative mixes. I honestly find fitting Amarrian ships
tedious, but have corpmates that swear by the Golden Banana or the Harbinger.
I specifically avoid recommending any Battleship hulls. This is because you don’t need a battleship
to run level fours, and they require a lot more skill training than any
battlecruiser to achieve similar results
I have seen many new corpmates lose their first battleship in a
seemingly innocuous L4 due to warp-scramming frigs or capacitor issues Here is another rule of thumb once you start
thinking about BS and larger hulls: If
you need more than one fitting module to make an entirely Tech II module BS
work, don’t fly it. Do not copy a fit
from Battleclinic or a corpmate without understanding why it works the way it
does.
Mission Strategies
Fly with multiple people. I recommend a group of 3-4
people/pilots. My ideal mission group
consists of two people playing two accounts.
One pilot flies something with a huge tank (see the Drake above) and
jumps into a pocket before everyone else, shoots everything, waits for every
hostile to target and attack his ship, and then the rest of the gang comes in
to mop up. The 2-3 support pilots can
fly just about anything. For a newer
player, this could be a DPS fit Cruiser or BC.
I personally love the Stealth Bomber loaded up with target
painters. Cheap and it makes things go
boom.
The goal of this setup is to pull missions quickly (2 people
flying 4 pilots will make more than 1 person chain pulling) while still keeping
the isk pool large. If you get past 3
distinct players, I find it to be a blast but financially ineffective. Also, the more players you add, the more you
dilute the LP and standing gains. Having
a slew of pilots also makes it easier to be choosey about your missions. Some are worth far more than others, an sometimes
you can get a few missions at the same time in the same system, which reduces
travel time.
The Kicker
Salvage. Most players
hate it. I bought a corpmate a Noctis so
I could stop doing it. But salvage makes
money if you are smart about it. If you
have 3+ pilots in a mission fleet, strongly consider having someone salvage, or
rotate salvage duties. Also agree on
payout beforehand. I use the following
formula: The salvager gets half of what
he sells the salvage for, and everyone else gets a cut equal to the time they
helped for. And for the love of god, do
not just blindly sell to buy orders without looking first. Depending on your luck , salvage is worth
about 75% to 125% of the bounties and payout of a mission, so take advantage of
this. Also, if you find selling and/or
refining salvage interesting, you may be a budding Industrialist ™!
Final Thoughts
If you are in a corp and are working on standing, you can
reach agreements with other players to stay logged in and part of a fleet while
they grind standing in exchange for the same courtesy to them later on. You can also do this with alts.
Kill missions that target other factions will tend to tank
your faction standing real fast. This
may be one of the biggest arguments for having two accounts to run missions
with: You can decline on one character,
and start pulling on the second.
Eve-Survival.org is a great place to read about other player’s
experiences with missions.
Learn damage and resist characteristics of the various
pirate factions and fit accordingly if needed.
I’ll have more to say about other methods of making money in
future articles.
Fly safe!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)